The Story of Patient “J.K.”

In July of 1992, a patient identified only as “J.K.” went to Steven Chase Brigham’s New Jersey abortion facility. She requested treatment for the demise of her 22-23 week fetus. To avoid depersonalizing her, I’ll call her Jessie.

According to medical board documents, Brigham failed to perform even routine testing in this high-risk patient. Instead, he inserted laminaria, and sent Jessie to her home over an hour away, instructing her to return next day.

He inserted new laminaria the next day, rupturing Jessie’s membranes. He sent Jessie home again, with instruction to take oral antibiotics and go to his New York facility next day to complete procedure. The medical board faulted Brigham with failure to admit Jessie to a hospital due to the risk of infection or life-threatening disseminated intravascular coagulopathy. Not surprisingly, Jessie developed a fever and was admitted to a hospital via the emergency room.

Board documents also say Brigham claimed that if Jessie had been adequately dilated, he would have accompanied her to his NY office to complete the abortion. The board noted of Brigham, supposedly an expert in such cases, “He claimed to have performed the abortion as a ‘charity case’ and was ‘surprised’ … that a patient presenting with an intrauterine fetal demise at 23 weeks would have received appropriate care at any area hospital without regard to her ability to pay.” Nevertheless, Brigham “acknowledged that he charged J.K. a ‘small fee,’ ‘$200, $300, $400.'”

Brigham testified that he did not feel Jessie suffered “a significant complication” in that she was hospitalized only two days and did not require a transfusion.

Source: New Jersey medical board Interim Decision and Order

Credit: Christina Dunigan

Share on Facebook

Abortion Patient “A.W

A woman identified in New Jersey medical board documents as “A.W.” (identified in New York documents as “Patient B”) was referred by Hershey Medical Center in Pennsylvania for an abortion by Brigham at his Flushing Women’s Center May 7-9, 1992. To avoid depersonalizing her, I’ll call her Anne.

The pregnancy was estimated at 24.5 weeks, past the legal limit for elective abortions in Pennsylvania. A D&E was initiated with the insertion of laminaria (dialators).

The following day, the abortion procedure was initiated under ultrasound. Brigham removed a fetal arm and part of the placenta, then detected a perforation. Although he was reaching for bony parts of the fetus and instead grasping soft tissues, he continued to grasp and pull with his instruments.This caused an 8-10 cm uterine laceration. Brigham perforated Anne’s sigmoid colon, and caused extensive cutting of the connective tissues of the colon.

Anne required a colostomy, and the removal of a 16 cm segment of her colon. Brigham admitted that he did not know what he was grasping with forceps, “the ultrasound picture was not consistent with what he felt,” but he “opened his forceps wider and grasped again, with force.”

Anne was transferred by ambulance to a hospital. She arrived in shock, and 3-4 units of packed cells were transfused.

In addition to the damage to her uterus and colon, Anne suffered damage to both ureters damaged. The medical board noted, “While perforation of the uterus is a known risk … and perhaps could be excused under some circumstances, the injuries caused by Respondent went far beyond perforation. … It is unacceptable for a practitioner to move his instrument in the body cavity without a clear understanding of their location. … The resultant injuries, particularly those to the bowel and ureters illustrate the point. These injuries were entirely unnecessary and caused by compounded acts outside accepted standards of medicine.” The board also noted that Brigham “portrays the very extensive injury to A.W. as a slip of the instrument.”

Sources: New Jersey medical board Interim Decision and Order; Administrative Review Board Decision and Order Number ARB No. 94-98 & No. 94-146; State Board for Professional Medical Conduct Statement of Charges; Newark Star-Ledger 1-7-94; Philadelphia Inquirer 12-15-94; Courier-Post 12-22-94; Atlantic City Press 12-15-94 Rockland Journal-News 12-10-94; New York Medical Board Statement of Charges (beginning at the bottom of page 7) and Findings (scroll to bottom of page 36)

Credit: Christina Dunigan

Share on Facebook

Texas Clinics Dump Medical Waste in Trash

There have been many incidents of clinics disposing of “medical waste” (Often including unborn babies) in the trash. By law, all remains of abortions must be sent to a pathologist.

This is done for the woman’s safety- the pathologist must ascertain that the abortion was complete- no parts of the baby or placenta were left behind. Any “tissue” left behind can cause infection which can endanger a woman’s fertility and even her life.

So instances of clinics dumping babies in the trash are more than just gruesome examples of abortion providers’ disregard for the dignity of the babies they kill- they are also examples of malpractice.

In a June of 2011, The Texas Commission on Environmental Quality (TCEQ) determined that a clinic affiliated with the Whole Women’s Health chain was illegally dumping the remains of aborted babies and other medical waste in Austin.

According to the an article that can be found here Whole Women’s Health is being charged with “Failure to prevent the disposal of treated fetuses at a municipal solid waste landfill” and “Failure to ensure that the labels placed on each medical waste container show the weight of the container.”

See the official TCEQ report here.

Another Texas clinic in the same chain in McAllen, Texas, was found to have thrown out other abortion related garbage such as bloody cannulas (the tubes used tear apart unborn babies in the first trimester) bloody human tissue that included what may be the intestines of aborted babies, syringes, and documents with the full names of abortion patients on them.

See the TCEQ report on the McAllen incident here.

See pictures of the items found in McAllen (GRAPHIC)

Share on Facebook

Abortionists in California: Why They Stopped

Abortion doctors leave their practices for a variety of reasons. Some have a change of heart. Sometimes the work itself takes a toll.

But sometimes they stop performing abortions because they have to. A disturbingly large number of abortionists have run afoul of medical boards and many have had their licenses revoked. A few have even been charged with murder or manslaughter for the deaths of women in their care.
In fact, Community Access to Reproductive Services (CARES) has been actively investigating the harassment and discrimination of abortion doctors by the Medical Board of California (MBC). CARES found in a recent study that nearly 90% of doctors of freestanding abortion clinics are on probation with the Medical Board.
Here are the reasons abortion doctors left practice in California over the past few years:
Lawson Akpulonu: Bench warrant for rape.
Haifa Azawi: Unknown.
Kim Beauchamp: Revoked for violating probation.
Leon Belous: Retired.
Bruce Bob: Converted, now refuses to do abortions.
Kurt Bochner: Retired.
Nicholas Braemer: License revoked for negligence against women.
Albert Brown: Suicide.
Mahlon Cannon: License revoked for death of female patients.
Cathy Cantrell: Unknown.
William Carey: Unknown.
Irving Cushner Deceased.
Mohamed Dia: License revoked for negligence against women.
Gerard Droege: Unknown.
John Dupont: Retired.
Karl Evelyn: No longer does abortions.
Suresh Gandotra: Bench warrant for arrest in death of woman.
Gordon Goei: License revoked for violating probation.
Paul Goldstein: No longer does abortions.
Virgil Graham: No longer does abortions.
Saihb Halil: License revoked for negligence against women.
Alicia Ruiz Hanna: In prison for murder of woman.
Elaine Hanson: No longer does abortions.
Thomas Kelly: No longer does abortions.
Philip R. King: Surrendered license.
William Kroutil: Retired.
Young Ho Kwon Revoked for violation of probation.
Arthur LaRose: Deceased.
Kirsten Lee: No longer does abortions.
John Lischke: No longer does abortions.
Anna Lopez: Unknown.
Edward Lishman: Unable to locate.
Ahmad Mehran: Unable to locate.
Ben Major: Deceased.
James T. McMahan: Deceased.
Phillip Milgram: Moved to Las Vegas.
A. Mitchell: Retired.
Richard Neal: Retired.
Leslie Orleans Deceased.
Arthur Pederson: Retired.
Steven Plaxe: No longer does abortions.
William Quesenberry: Retired to Arizona.
Michael Rich: Retired.
Scott Ricke: License revoked for negligence against women.
Clyde Rights: Retired.
Carol Schmidt Unknown.
Allan Silver: No longer does abortions.
Bruce Steir: License revoked for negligence in death of woman.
Gary Stewart: Deceased.
William Swartz: Retired.
Sean Tayebi: Just gone.
Bertha Bugarin: criminal conviction, currently in jail in LAC
Joseph R. Durante: deceased
Phillip Rand: License Revoked for Negligence
Nolan G. Jones: License Revoked
Ripton Wade: Deceased.

Over 30% of the abortionists in this list who left practice did so because their licenses were revoked or they were arrested. Some abortionists were impossible to locate or left for unknown reasons. Out of the abortionists who left for known reasons, just short of half stopped practice because of disciplinary action taken against them.

Note: Since I posted this, a reader made me aware of some other abortionists in California who are no longer providing abortion.

Bertha Bugarin-criminal conviction, currently in jail in LAC
Joseph R. Durante,.-deceased
Phillip Rand, -License Revoked for Negligence
Nolan G. Jones-License Revoked

Share on Facebook

Abortionists Are Not Held Accountable for Mistakes

Abortion is one of the most frequently performed surgical procedures in the United States–yet it is the least regulated. It is the only elective surgical procedure that I know of in which the doctor performing the procedure is not responsible for follow-up care, nor does he or she take an active role in dealing with the complications.

Not only this, but the very nature of abortion clinics, which practice in isolation from the rest of the medical community, keeps the abortion provider free from accountability for these complications.

Those who support abortion on demand will claim that the reported complication rate for abortions is low. They may be right. Not necessarily because there are few complications, but because the complications are underreported. They are underreported because there is no accurate process in place today to quantify the harmful repercussions of abortion. The abortion industry has successfully kept abortion and abortionists free from the type of review, regulation, and accountability that is an integral part of the rest of the medical profession. Let me give you some real life examples.

I recently took care of a woman who almost died because she’d had an abortion. A few days before I saw her, she’d had an abortion because of a positive pregnancy test. Now, after an abortion, the clinic will examine the remains which have been scraped from the uterus to take inventory of fetal parts in order to ensure that the entire pregnancy was totally eliminated. This clinic noted that there were no fetal parts, which meant that the pregnancy had not been in the uterus.

This situation is known as an ectopic pregnancy, where the pregnancy is not in the womb, but in the fallopian tube. An ectopic pregnancy is a life-threatening condition; the ectopic must be removed or it will grow to a size that will rupture the fallopian tube and result in massive internal bleeding that can kill the mother.

In any legitimate medical facility, a woman with an ectopic pregnancy would have an immediate ultrasound to assess the ectopic, be admitted to the hospital, and have surgery before it could rupture and potentially take her life. In this abortion facility, the woman was sent home and told to call her doctor. Unfortunately, time was not on her side — before she ever had the chance, her ectopic pregnancy ruptured, she was rushed to the ER by ambulance, and taken immediately to the operating room.

Had this quality of care been provided by any other medical provider–family physician, obstetrician, or emergency physician–it would be considered grossly negligent. By an abortion provider, it does not even cause a stir. In fact it goes unnoted and unreported.

A few years ago, a young woman about twenty years old came to the ER because she was feeling very sick. She’d become increasingly ill ever since the abortion she’d had about a week earlier. I had her admitted to the hospital from the ER with a severe pneumonia. The following days revealed that the pneumonia was just a part of the problem–she had overwhelming sepsis, which is infection throughout her entire body which had, at its source, the abortion.

This woman died. The admitting physician never reported the incident as abortion-related, nor did she inform the abortion provider of the results of his “care.” He was still practicing, without the slightest idea that his intervention had led to his patient’s death.

The medical diagnosis reads “severe pain”–the real cause is abortion. The record reads “vaginal bleeding”–the real cause is abortion. The operative note says “ruptured ectopic pregnancy and internal hemorrhage”–the real cause is abortion. The autopsy states “cause of death–overwhelming sepsis”–the real cause is abortion.

There is no other practice of medicine where people can suffer and die from complications of your intervention without your being in some way professionally accountable, involved in their care, and at the very least, made aware of it–except abortion.

Abortion is a horrible abuse of the practice of medicine, ending one and a half million lives every year, yet our nation has made it legal. It is an invasive medical procedure, which in my own singular experience as ONE DOCTOR, has led to the death of one woman and the near death of another, yet its practitioners are not held to the same standards of care as the rest of the medical community.

Abortion is bad medicine. It is bad because it pushes sloppy medical care upon women who have been led to believe that their only choice is to abort their babies. It will always be bad medicine because it takes away an innocent human life. Our nation, our community, our mothers, sisters, daughters deserve better.

Dr. Lenora W. Berning, M.D. is a physician with Lancaster Emergency Associates LTD., at Lancaster General Hospital in Pennsylvania. This article is excerpted from a press statement made by Dr. Berning. Reprinted with permission.

Originally published in The Post-Abortion Review, 8(2), April-June 2000. Copyright 2000, Elliot Institute. (Used with permission)

Elliot Institute, PO Box 7348, Springfield, IL 62791-73480.afterabortion.org

Additional material is posted at www.afterabortion.org

Share on Facebook

Abortion Leads to Woman Having Fingers Amputated

After her 1981 abortion by Dr. X, Naomi had to have portions of three fingers amputated because the drugs that she was given were improperly administered.”

Los Angeles County Superior Court case number W EC 073497

Mark Crutcher “Lime 5: Exploited by Choice ” (Denton, Texas: Life Dynamics Incorporated, 1996) 189

Share on Facebook

Woman Left in Coma after Abortion, Needs Nursing Home Care for the Rest of Her Life

Nina underwent an abortion by Dr. X on January 2, 1988. During the procedure, she went into cardiac arrest, but the doctor did not have the training or equipment to deal with it. As a result, Nina was left comatose, legally incapacitated, and in need of nursing home care for the remainder of her life.”

Wayne County (MI) Circuit Court case number 90 – 016792 NH

Mark Crutcher “Lime 5: Exploited by Choice ” (Denton, Texas: Life Dynamics Incorporated, 1996) 70

Share on Facebook

Mother of Two in “Permanent Vegetative State” after Abortion

“Laverne” a 35-year-old mother of two, underwent an abortion at a Washington DC area abortion clinic in November 1987. The nurse improperly placed a tube for anesthesia into her esophagus instead of her trachea. Before the mistake was discovered, the oxygen supply to her brain was cut off, leaving Laverne in a permanent vegetative state.”

Washington DC Superior Court civil action number 10616 – 87

 

Share on Facebook

Abortion Leaves Woman Seriously Brain-Damaged

“Shelby” age 50, had an abortion by Dr. X. Immediately after the abortion began, she had a reaction to a drug the abortionist had given her and experienced a grossly abnormal elevation in blood pressure. The doctor dismissed the reaction as transient and left after completing the procedure. Half an hour later, Shelby went into cardiopulmonary arrest. The resulting lack of oxygen left her severely and permanently brain-damaged. She now requires 24-hour care and lives in a nursing home.”

Cook County Illinois Circuit Court case number 80L 1539; Illinois appellate court, first district, case number 1 – 89 – 2165, 1 – 89 – 2357, Associated Press 4/15/89, 4/16/89, 4/17/89; York Daily Record 4/17/89

Mark Crutcher “Lime 5: Exploited by Choice ” (Denton, Texas: Life Dynamics Incorporated, 1996) 70

Share on Facebook

Planned Parenthood Neglect Injures Woman

“On August 30, 1990 Diona went to a Planned Parenthood facility for pre-abortion counseling and a gonorrhea culture. The abortionist proceeded with the abortion prior to obtaining the results of the culture. On September 2 and 3rd, Diana called Planned Parenthood to complain of cramps and fever, but was unable to reach anyone. On September 4 they returned her call, and told her that since her temperature was only 99.5, she should keep taking her Tylenol. Diona’s symptoms worsened, and on September 11 she was admitted to a local hospital with “bilateral tubo-ovarian abscesses.” She underwent laparoscopicy, pelvic laparotomy, removal of lesions, drainage of abscesses, and a D&C. The results of the gonorrhea culture were reported to Planned Parenthood staff on September 4, but they did not attempt to advise Diona of this until September 11, after she was already hospitalized.”

This woman was lucky to have survived. Here are some stories from women who are not as lucky.

Philadelphia County “PA” Court of Common Pleas case number 92 – 04 – 683

Mark Crutcher “Lime 5: Exploited by Choice ” (Denton, Texas: Life Dynamics Incorporated, 1996) 67

Share on Facebook