How the legal abortion limit in New York was decided

In 1970, New York State legalized abortion and placed the legal limit at 24 weeks. Abortions could be performed up to that point. Dr. Bernard Nathanson, former abortionist turned pro-life, tells how this upward limit was determined:

23 week 3d sonogram
23 week 3d sonogram

“I had the opportunity to ask Assemblywoman Constance Cook about how the architects of the bill had arrived at the 24 week limit. She told me, a little apologetically, that doctors regarded the 20th week as the point at which the expulsion is no longer an abortion but a premature delivery, and the fetus is an “infant” if born alive, or a “stillbirth” if born dead. The older English Common Law figured viability, the point at which a prematurely delivered fetus had a reasonable chance to survive, at 28 weeks. At this point in her exegesis she paused a beat or two, then said: “We split the difference.” And that, children, is how the laws are written.”

Bernard Nathanson with Richard Ostling Aborting America (New York: Pinnacle Books, 1979) 69

Today, thanks to Roe Vs. Wade there is no longer any upper limit to abortion in NY or some other states. Unless a state has passed legislation banning late term abortions, it is legal to abort up until the day of birth.

Share on Facebook

Author: Sarah

Sarah Terzo is a pro-life writer and blogger. She is on the board of The Consistent Life Network and PLAGAL +

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

thirty two + = thirty four